Table of Contents
Arnold writes:[1]
If we turn from the Bedouins to consider the attitude of the settled inhabitants of the towns and the non-Arab population towards the new religion, we do not find that the Arab conquest was so rapidly followed by conversions to Islam.
The Christians of the great cities of the eastern provinces of the Byzantine empire seem for the most part to have remained faithful to their ancestral creed, to which indeed they still in large numbers cling.
Arnold notes that Arab conquest over the Christian lands did not lead to large-scale conversions. Conversions happened afterwards, and they were willing conversions after Christians saw the justice and toleration of Islām . Rather, they preferred the rule of Islām over that of their fellow Christians.
Arnold goes on to explain how Christians, fearing that they might be persecuted by other Christians on grounds of centuries old sectarian differences that had arisen, willing and eagerly received government by Muslims:
But Heraclius shared the fate of so many would-be peace-makers: for not only did the controversy [about the nature of Christ] blaze up again all the more fiercely, but he himself was stigmatised as a heretic and drew upon himself the wrath of both parties.
Indeed, so bitter was the feeling he aroused that there is strong reason to believe that even a majority of the orthodox subjects of the Roman Empire, in the provinces that were conquered during this emperor's reign, were the well-wishers of the Arabs ; they regarded the emperor with aversion as a heretic, and were afraid that he might commence a persecution in order to force upon them his Monotheistic opinions.[2]
They therefore readily — and even eagerly — received the new masters who promised them religious toleration, and were willing to compromise their religious position and their national independence if only they could free themselves from the immediately impending danger. The people of Emessa closed the gates of their city against the army of Heraclius and told the Muslims that they preferred their government and justice to the injustice and oppression of the Greeks.[3]