ABUIYAAD
Reports News Search

Shaykh Zayd al-Madkhalī: It is Correct to Exercise Caution Regarding Those With Questionable Statements and Positions


Shaykh Zayd al-Madkhalī (رحمه الله) was asked:[1]

Is it considered correct or not to be cautious of promoting some of those from whom questionable positions and words have appeared until their affair becomes clear?

His answer:

Firstly, I say: It is not permissible to hold a negative opinion regarding Ahl al-Sunnah wal-Jamāʿah, those who adhere to the Sunnah, show allegiance to its adherents and keep their company while distancing themselves from the people of desires and innovations.

But it is permissible to have a negative opinion of the one who brings reasons for it, such as :

  • the one you observe becoming angry when Ahl al-Bidaʿ are mentioned,
  • or [becoming angry for] those who have been spoken against, or warned against with a general warning,
  • or you hear him defending them as groups or individuals,
  • or when there are indications which make clear that a person is a diluter (mumayyiʿ) of the methodology of Ahl al-Sunnah.

Hence, you should not promote him, nor direct others to take (knowledge) from him until his soundness becomes evident to you. Then you can direct the students of knowledge to take knowledge from him. Or until his allegiance to Ahl al-Bidaʿ becomes evident to you, even if it was through merely promoting them and not speaking against him. So beware of him and warn (others) from him, and how true are what was said by the poet:

Whatever traits a person may have, even if he believes they are hidden from others, will be revealed (eventually).

So such an individual and whoever is like him, then you, O caller, must explain his error to him in a clear and explicit way, by presenting the evidences to him by which error is distinguished from truth. Then, observe which faction he advances to, which group he associates with, and with whom he keeps company (through visitations).

Know that whoever hides his innovation from Ahl al-Sunnah, then his company (i.e. true allegiance) will not be hidden.

Notes

01  Recently there has been some controversy regarding the issue of scholars warning against those from Ahl al-Sunnah who fail in their scholarly duty to uphold the truth when they are in a position to do so, and particularly in tribulations to which they have proximity, where their position of support would aid Ahl al-Sunnah and lead to consolidation and preponderance truth and diminishing of error, falsehood and oppression, through which splits are contained and minimised. An example is that of Shaykh Sulaymān al-Ruḥaylī, who has been warned against with a warning that does not constitute tabdīʿ (heresification) but which has wisdoms and legislated objectives.

02  When doubts are presented regarding these types of warnings, they undermine the principles and methodology of Aḥl al-Ḥadīth, the Salafī methodology, which ensure the integrity of transmission of knowledge, whether related to the truthfulness of reports, or the soundness of positions towards individuals and tribulations. These positions serve as historical signposts along the path, they become fixed over the centuries and allow future generations to follow the course of this path, whose boundaries have been preserved through such positions.

03  For example, there was a time when Muḥammad al-Maghrāwī was refuted and warned against for his misguided views in matters of takfīr and revolution, but Abū al-Ḥasan al-Maʾribī aligned with him, made defences of him and tried to dilute the methodology to this end. Hence, caution was initially taken regarding his affair, and then he was warned against for apparent reasons, and eventually tabdīʿ was made of him and his followers after the proof was established against them.

If such warnings against those who become obstacles towards valid refutations of those opposing the foundations of the Sunnah were undermined at the time, it would have compromised the purity of the path, because then the correct ruling on a man speaking with takfīr of the ummah and revolution would have been dismissed and the path would be compromised, because this would open the door of accommodation for others of the same ilk.

04  Likewise, when ʿAlī Ḥasan al-Ḥalabī who kept ties with the jamʿiyyāt and to misguided people like ʿAdnān Arʿūr, after they had been refuted and warned against. His likes said: “We are still advising him”, and other such affairs which comprise tamyīʿ. Though scholars and shaykhs have already refuted, exposed and warned against individuals with clear evidences, these were just flimsy excuses to justify continued association and company with the disparaged and refuted. To justify it, false principles were even devised in the affair of al-jarḥ wal-taʿdīl.

05  If it was said: “Why are you warning against al-Maʾribī, he is not a Jahmī” at a particular junction in time, or “al-Ḥalabī” at a particular junction in time, or “al-Ruḥaylī, Ibrāhīm or Sulaymān, he is not a Jahmī?” This can lead people to believe that warnings can only be made on the basis of major innovation, such as Rafḍ, Tajahhum, Khārijiyyah and the likes, and this is incorrect.

The sphere of warning is wider and broader than the sphere of tabdīʿ and it is an important part of the methodology of Ahl al-Sunnah, because justified warnings with legislated objectives preserve the integrity of transmission and the signposts of the path.

So this affair that Shaykh Zayd al-Madkhalī has mentioned is from the religion, it is from the methodology, and it cannot be undermined by dubious arguments. Undermining this principle is incorrect and harmful.

06  The statements from other scholars, whether from Shaykh Rabīʿ bin Hādī, Shaykh Muqbil or Shaykh Ṣāliḥ Āl al-Shaykh have their own contexts and do not invalidate or oppose this specific issue of methodology.

07  This issue of methodology addresses the question of: “Will there be any Salafī path left?”, and this comes before the issue of “No one will be left”, because in order for anyone to be left, we have to have an intact path. This is why al-Maʾribī, al-Ḥalabī and al-Ruḥaylī types become obstacles and gateways for the loss and compromise of the path itself. If we do not have these warnings, this is the place where the statement “No one will be left” also has its place, even more so, because it means everyone will start taking paths in pursuit of knowledge, not knowing where these paths will eventually lead them. They might end up in gatherings of Ṣūfis, or promoting books that praise heretical innovators.

May Allāḥ grant success to all in what He loves and is pleased with.

Arabic text:



Footnotes
1. Al-Ajwibah al-Athariyyah ʿan al-Masāʾil al-Manhajiyyah, (pp. 96–97).




© Abu Iyaad — Benefits in dīn and dunyā

Search

Enter your search term and hit enter.