ABUIYAAD
Reports News Search

Shaykh Muqbil bin Hādī: On Taking Disputes About Democracy, Rulership, Obedience and Rebellion to the Scholars for Judgement


The image pictured with speech of Shaykh Muqbil (رحمه الله) was posted on social media (20 November 2026) with the following remarks added:

Sitting with scholars breaks their back.

The reliable scholars handle disputes.

Not the unstable, unknowns on X or recently raised individuals.

That’s how to stop agendas. Not rants or outbursts.

It is important that we remain truthful and respect the speech of scholars through academic and intellectual integrity, and preserve and present the historical contexts in which they were made, and I refer to “contexts” and “meta-contexts” when addressing such matters, because this allows us to unravel the thought process of the person—in this case an unnamed majhūl—posting such speech with ulterior motives.

The Source and Context

This entire section stems from page 418 to 440 (22 page), and the questions are from Algeria in the early 1990s, relating to the fitnah of politics, democracy and rebellion, which involved bloodshed and questions about ʿAlī bil-Ḥāj, ʿAbbāsī Madanī and the Islāmic Salvation Front. This was around the time that the fitnah was emerging, due to these individuals mixing Salafiyyah with politics.

Shaykh Muqbil made observations against ʿAbbāsī Madanī in this respect, his praise of the Iranian revolution, and stated that though the Islāmic Salvation Front were oppressed by the government, they have innovations with them in these matters, their entrance into democracy and elections, and that in the daʿwah to Allāh, which is the foundation, these aḥzāb and the associated politics are not needed. He went on to speak about democracy and elections and their ṭāghūtī, evil nature.

He went on to answer a question about a ḥadīth regarding the Imām (ruler) being a shield behind whom fighting should take place, about this being a condition for fighting, and he said that having an Imām is a condition, but also tamkīn, which is having empowerment, meaning you are not weak.

He then answered a question on the hadith about the rulers who do not follow Prophetic guidance and have the hearts of devils in bodies of men, and mentioned that when clear kufr is seen and there is ability to remove them, in that case it would be permitted to contend with them but otherwise, they must remain patient.

He was then asked a question about assassinations of government-affiliated people, and he advised them against it, and said that this has a very narrow application and is for those who are heads of disbelief who abuse Allāh, His Messenger, His religion and the Believers, such as Kaʿb in al-Ashraf.

Then there was a question about shaving the beard and other compromises to avoid clamp downs from the government, and Shaykh Muqbil (رحمه الله) said that aid from Allāh cannot be expected through disobedience, and he cited verses from the Qurʾān in this regard. He then answered a question about a student of knowledge fearing for himself when travelling by air, whether he is allowed to shave his beard, and the Shaykh said that if he was to be imprisoned just for some days, then no. But if he fears harm to himself, his wealth or he is harmed with something unbearable, then there is no harm in it and to wear trousers and the likes.

Then he is asked a question about the afflictions befalling the Prophets and Messengers, are they from sins, given the verses that say all calamities are due to sins. The Shaykh (رحمه الله) said that calamities can be due to sins, or they can be for testing people, without any sin being their cause, in order to raise that person, and give him a higher rank in Paradise.

Then he is asked a question about Allāh aiding this religion through a sinful man and then about group called al-Hijrah wal-Takfīr, saying of them that they are Khārijites, followers of Shukrī Muṣṭafā from Egypt, and being oppressed and imprisoned led them to this Takfīrī ideology. Then he is asked about Jamāʾah al-Tablīgh and he said they are innovators, Ṣūfīs from India, against which caution is taken.

Then he is asked a question about distinctions between ʿaqīdah (creed) and manhaj (methodology) and, sharīʿah (law) and akhlāq (morals), and here he speaks about the jamāʿāt who are upon other than the methodology of the Salaf who have split the ummah, the political aḥzāb such as al-Ikhwān and al-Takfīr and others, and these jamāʿāt are headed by misguided individuals.

It is here that the Shaykh mentions that some people supported the Islamic Salvation Front with a sum equalling 80 thousand Yemeni riyāls at that time, and had they given this to students, or opened Islāmic schools, this would have been better.

In this context (of the aḥzāb) the Shaykh then says that if a Ḥizbī comes to you, wanting to debate you should say just as Imām Mālik said to the innovator wanting to debate him: “What if you dominate me”, and he said “You follow me”, and he asked: “Then what if another comes to debate me and overwhelms me?” He said: “Then you follow him”, so Imām Mālik said: “In that case, our religion becomes subject to fluctuation. Go to a doubter like yourself (to debate), as for me, I am upon firmness in my religion.”

This is where the paragraph occurs from where the above quote was extracted:

Shaykh Muqbil mentioned in the paragraph from page 434 how the Ikhwānīs flee from taking issues of democracy, pluralism, house of representatives, code of honour and coordination (of power) with Baʿthists and Nāsserites to the scholars for judgement, as to what the truth is in these issues.

The rest of the discussion is generally about ḥizbiyyah and what the aḥzāb are involved in, of polluting the religion with blameworthy politics, and about Baʿthism and Communism and how ḥizbiyyah is like political governance in which there is lying and deception, then so it is with ḥizbiyyah, it is founded on these things.

Then there is a question about ʿAbd al-Raḥmān ʿAbd al-Khāliq, and the Shaykh (رحمه الله) explains about his deviation and entry into blameworthy politics through democracy and elections, saying how his daʿwah and that of ʿAbd Allāh al-Sabt was calamitous upon the Salafī, Sunnī daʿwah.

Then there is a question about some people who fled to the mountains, from the fighting and slaughter in Algeria, and when they can they come and revolt against the ruler. The Shaykh mentioned again that it is when they see clear, manifest kufr and when there is ability, and the outcome will not favour the interests of foreign nations or give power to heretics from Baʿthists, Nāsserites, Secularists and others, and that we must protect the blood of the Muslims.

The rest of the questions are about issues connected to seeking knowledge, and the prayer and other affairs.

Notes, Comments and Questions

01  The speech of Shaykh Muqbil (رحمه الله) is connected to issues of democracy, aḥzāb, rebellion, obedience to the ruler, patience upon tyranny and the dangers of mixing politics with Salafiyyah.

02  The quote that has been extracted refers to ḥizbīs and innovators, as it was preceded with the speech of Imām Mālik (رحمه الله) regarding debating. So with respect to these ḥizbīs we are not to debate, but instead, say to them: “Let us go to the scholars and take our dispute with you on these matters to them.”

03  This speech has been quoted in the context of recent ʿumrah trips (November 2026) wherein various players in the daʿwah scene have congregated with certain mashāyikh, and whoever posted this statement, the majhūl, appears to be making a statement to other Salafīs through this speech of Shaykh Muqbil (رحمه الله) which actually refers to the innovators and ḥizbīs who have grave errors in the fields of rulership, obedience, and blameworthy politics.

04  As for the statement:

Sitting with scholars breaks their back.

Al-ḥamdu lillāh, we agree with the speech of Shaykh Muqbil (رحمه الله) that to the ḥizbīs and innovators, sitting with senior scholars and returning to them to clarify principles regarding rulership, governance, obedience, rebellion, democracy and so on, so that blameworthy politics can be separated from legislated politics, that it breaks their back. We do not know of any Salafī with a basic understanding of creed and methodology that disagrees with this and to whom such speech or scholarly rhetoric can be applied to.

05  As for the statement:

The reliable scholars handle disputes.

During the 90s, the great Imāms of the era, Imām al-Albānī, Imām Ibn Bāz, Imām Ibn al-ʿUthaymīn (رحمه الله) and many other scholars such as Shaykh Rabīʿ bin Hādī, Shaykh Muḥammad Amān al-Jāmī and others, they clarified these issues, and they judged between the people of desires who mixed political ambitions with Salafiyyah, and diverted the pure Salafī daʿwah from its direction and wasted the Salafī youth, and those who held firm to the Sunnah and its foundations.

It is scholars of their calibre, those who did not remain silent, hidden and elusive, who fulfilled their duty and handled the disputes of the disputants: between Shaykh Muqbil and the likes of ʿAbd al-Raḥmān ʿAbd al-Khāliq, or between Shaykh Rabīʿ and Ibn Jibrīn, Bakr Abū Zayd, the Quṭbiyyah and the Surūriyyah, until they made the truth as clear as the daylight sun regarding these grave and serious issues regarding politics, ḥizbiyyah and the methodologies of the Khārijites affecting nations and the course and direction of the Salafī daʿwah.

Shaykh al-Albānī judged in the matter of Rabīʿ and Sayyid Quṭb, Safar and Salmān and others. As did Shaykh Bin Bāz and Shaykh Ibn al-ʿUthaymīn, by way of example, may Allāh reward them with a tremendous reward. I do not know of any Salafī who contests the fact that it is reliable scholars like those mentioned who handle such disputes.

06  As for the statement:

Not the unstable, unknowns on X or recently raised individuals.

The unstable are those who shift their positions and deny what they once knew. In the days of Shaykh Muqbil (رحمه الله) his students use to scribble over cereal boxes which had pictures of people, due to the severe prohibition of taṣwīr, out of veneration for the Tawḥīd of Allāh.

The unknowns are those who make politically-motivated posts anonymously and are not willing to put their names to their claims and assertions, and it’s ironic that this post is itself from a majhūl.

As for individuals, it is Allāh who raises and lowers people on the basis of their veneration and aid for the Sunnah and its foundations, and we ask Him not to disgrace us through our sins and shortcomings and to grant us success in all of what He loves and is pleased with.

07  As for the statement:

That’s how to stop agendas. Not rants or outbursts.

This post, the contextual misquote and what appears to be its application to upright, truth-loving and truth-seeking Salafīs, zealous for the Sunnah and its foundations, who are actually in line with, and upon the very intent of Shaykh Muqbil (رحمه الله) is itself a rant and an outburst and emanates from someone who does not know what is flowing from his head and his keyboard.

When you go back to the speech of the scholars, and restore their sanctity by purifying them from people’s desires, remove the pollution added to them, and give them their correct meta-context, that’s how you stop agendas.

Finally, I request the identity of the person who posted this speech so that he can be advised not to fool around with the statements of the scholars, violate them and strip them of the sanctity of their original context and correct application for the purposes of propaganda and stupefying the idiots.

As for Salafīs who venerate the scholars, their guidance and their insightful statements, they are immune from this 21st century cyber-propaganda and see straight through it, and it is because they are still upon what they were upon in the 90s, and have never changed, shifted, or flipped, only by Allāh’s mercy, bounty and success.

Closing Notes

We are in a dangerous era in which sound-byte digs and refutations do nothing but cause more and more confusion to already hyper-sensitised and scattered minds. We have gone far, far away from the 90s when people would actually carefully read and grasp things. This is why there is so much fickleness and shallowness, and people are swayed by the flimsiest of things, in the absence of a discerning criterion, just because they appear to come from students of the scholars who perhaps no longer represent what those scholars were actually about, but have reduced them to quote-mining repositories.

To take lofty statements of great historical and contemporary significance, when they represent the struggle between truth and falsehood, between Salafiyyah and Hizbiyyah and Khārijiyyah, and to co-opt such statements for application to truth-loving Salafīs who in reality are the ones most represented by such statements, and would be validated and vindicated by them, all for the sake of daʿwah turf wars, and base desires is a despicable deed, and does not emanate from an intelligent person, and perhaps these are the inherited idiots (ḥamqāʿ) that some have spoken about, and we have no way of knowing because the post is from a majhūl.

We ask Allāh for safety and success in what He loves and is pleased with and for the rectification of the daʿwah, āmīn.




© Abu Iyaad — Benefits in dīn and dunyā

Search

Enter your search term and hit enter.